Why Do Common People Expect Free Services Solely from Doctors?

I recently made the decision to stop using Quora, primarily due to the constant removal of my personal and valuable answers. This has led me to question and delve deeper into societal expectations, particularly those toward the medical profession. One of the prevailing ideas that concern me is the notion that doctors, especially in cultures like those in India and Indic societies, are supposed to provide services for free, akin to a charitable act. However, this is far from the reality today.

Doctors Are Not Above Human Needs

In today's world, especially in societies where material comforts are highly valued, it is astonishing that people still hold the belief that doctors should lead an ascetic life, providing their services for free. This expectation disregards the reality that doctors, like any other professional, require compensation for their work. The idea that a doctor's role is defined by charity and selflessness is a misrepresentation of the medical profession.

The Historical Context in India

The historical context in India adds another layer to this discussion. Ancient physicians and surgeons were often spiritual leaders or ascetics who lived a simple life, surviving through the support of the community they served. This traditional model, however, was embedded within a society where barter systems were common, and the economy was largely driven by basic needs. As society evolved, the dynamics changed.

Modern Society and the Medical Profession

Today, society is not solely driven by basic survival. Quality of life is an important factor, and people seek the best possible healthcare. This shift has resulted in a more sophisticated medical system that relies on technology, diagnostics, and comprehensive care. However, paradoxically, the same society expects doctors to operate on a bare minimum, similar to their ancient predecessors. This disconnect is stark.

The Cultural Influence and Media Representation

The portrayal of doctors in media plays a significant role in shaping public perception. Films often depict doctors as miracle workers who can resolve any medical issue with minimal resources. For instance, a doctor might diagnose and treat conditions ranging from pregnancy to cancer simply by performing a few manual tests and perhaps asking for a cup of tea and some biscuits in exchange. Such portrayals sometimes become the norm, leading to a distorted view of the medical profession.

The Balance Between Charity and Profession

The medical profession is a noble and honorable one, but it is also a profession with its own set of professional standards and ethical codes. The Hippocratic oath, which is the foundation of ethical medical practice, emphasizes the duty of doctors to provide the best care possible. It does not suggest that doctors should provide their services for free. In fact, seeking a fair remuneration is a recognition of the hard work and expertise involved in the practice of medicine.

Government Involvement and Market Distortions

Another issue that arises from the expectation of free healthcare is the role of the government. While it is important for the government to ensure access to basic healthcare, the idea that the government should control all aspects of health care, as seen in single-payer systems like Medicare-for-All, can lead to market distortions. Government intervention in wage and price controls often results in shortages of medical services, creating black markets and further deteriorating the quality of care.

Conclusion

The common expectation that doctors should provide their services for free is a reflection of a deeper cultural and societal issue. It is essential to understand the historical and modern context of the medical profession to appreciate its true value. Doctors, like any other professionals, deserve fair compensation for their invaluable work. It is also important to critique the media portrayals that distort the reality of the medical profession. Society needs to strike a balance between recognizing the sacrifices of doctors and respecting the need for fair compensation and accountability.