The Mask Debate: Why Some Feel a Need for Exceptionalism During the Pandemic

As the global pandemic continues to present challenges, one of the most debated aspects is the need for masks. While the medical community and public health officials strongly advocate for mask usage to prevent the spread of covid-19, some individuals feel a pressing need to obtain health exemptions. This article explores the reasons behind such feelings, particularly for those with specific respiratory conditions like asthma and COPD.

Why Health Exemptions for Masks?

The term "health exemption" for masks is often used to describe situations where individuals with certain conditions cannot safely wear masks due to breathing difficulties. Take, for example, someone like myself, who has both moderately severe asthma and COPD. I can wear various types of masks except for the N95. This brings up the question: do these individuals really need an exemption?

It is not uncommon for people with respiratory conditions to feel that they are at high risk of severe illness if they contract covid-19. But are they justified in seeking exemptions? The answer is no. If their condition is severe enough to prevent them from wearing a mask, they should be staying at home as much as possible. It is estimated that by 2030, the incidence of COPD will rise by 30% in the United States, and individuals with asthma are also at increased risk.

A Personal Experience

Recently, I went food shopping with my father. It was a warm and humid day, and I was already tired and a bit grumpy. Wearing a mask under these conditions was particularly challenging. For a healthy individual, masks may feel restrictive and uncomfortable, especially during hot weather.

As someone who understands the challenges of wearing a mask, I suggest finding alternative methods if a mask is not feasible. A cloth face covering or a plastic face shield can be effective alternatives. Face shields may actually be better than masks in certain situations, as some studies indicate they have better ventilation.

Debunking Phobias and Misconceptions

The perception that some people cannot breathe well while wearing masks often stems from a fear of close spaces rather than a physiological inability to breathe. Cloth masks, while porous, can still provide a sufficient barrier against droplets. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) recommends wearing masks to prevent the spread of the virus, and the use of face shields can be considered as an alternative.

During the pandemic, it is crucial that we all do our part to protect public health. If you are experiencing difficulties with wearing a mask, there are safer alternatives available. Staying home when possible and utilizing curbside pick-up for essential items can also minimize your risk.

Conclusion

The need for health exemptions for masks should be carefully considered and often avoided, especially for those with severe respiratory conditions. While it can be challenging, finding alternative methods can help ensure safety during these uncertain times. We must work together to curb the spread of covid-19 and protect our communities.